Banned Books Week Celebrates Texts That Some Want To Censor : NPR (Reuters) - A Stanford Law School assistant dean who was involved in the disruption of a conservative federal judge's speech at the school last spring is leaving the school. Screen for heightened risk individual and entities globally to help uncover hidden risks in business relationships and human networks. School violence. She also wants teachers to be educated in how to take actions seriously and education for students. The industry leader for online information for tax, accounting and finance professionals. At the Tuesday night meeting, some parents and students, however, feared it would dilute district efforts to make all students feel welcome at school. The Coronavirus Crisis NPR/Ipsos Poll: Nearly One-Third Of Parents May Stick With Remote Learning This year's responses showed positive trends as the nation continues to recover from the worst of. Brownsville is a city featured in the Texas map expansion DLC for American Truck Simulator. A law school spokeswoman provided Martinez statement but did not respond to requests for clarification about whether Steinbach was asked to step down. Texas school official says classrooms with books on Holocaust must Though there are estimates that only a handful of Satan Clubs are up and running, the groups raise significant questions about freedom of speech in K-12 public schools, particularly around religious issues topics I teach and write about frequently as a faculty member specializing in education law. Indeed, in a diverse and divided nation, that skill has never been more necessary or in shorter supply. "I know there's been some controversy but I don't honestly pay much attention to that, as much as some others here. A school district in Tennessee apologized after a middle school homework assignment at Sunset Middle School in Franklin, Tennessee, asked students to pretend that their families owned slaves and set "expectations" for them. "The Catholic Church is very clear in its teachings about justice for immigrants and refugees," McGuire wrote. Chapter 8 - Where to meet people like you - includes a guide to sex apps and gay bars to meet intimate partners. The Lookout is a free, daily email newsletter with news and happenings from all over Colorado. Heres hoping othersmany othersfollow their lead. The Ultimate Underground Music Showcase Survival Guide, From racketeering to dinosaur bones, here are 5 facts about the creation of Coors Field, Colorado weather: Denver could hit 100 degrees Monday and Tuesday as temperatures jump statewide, Wheat Ridge man among white nationalists convicted of conspiracy to riot at Idaho Pride event. New Phoenix Suns uniforms for 2023-24 NBA season teased by star on social media, 7-footer Bol Bol has chance to prove he's more than just a unique talent with Phoenix Suns. In that class, Hawn regularly addressed questions related to race, along with other potentially controversial issues. Texas A&M University announced on Friday that its president, M. Katherine Banks, will "retire immediately" amid controversy about the mishandling of a Black journalist's hire. Where do you stop? In doing so, the Post reified an ideologically narrowand morally certainposition on a larger platform. As an indicator of the scope of the challenges related to a lack of viewpoint diversity, it is worth noting that the Washington Post compounded the problem. I think its age appropriate if a child is interested in it and can ask the hard questions, Craig said. Instilling and enforcing teacher codes of conduct that stipulate that teachers are welcomed and encouraged to address age-appropriate controversial topics with students, so long as teachers provide students access to varying points of view when they do so, can go a long way towards threading this needle. Dayton, Ohio 45402, Gadfly Bites 7/24/23Beyond the Battle for the Budget, How to ensure twice-exceptional students don't slip through the cracks, Its time for Ohio to dump Reading Recovery. Just 18% of parents say their child's school taught about gender and sexuality in a way that clashed with their family's values; just 19% say the same about race and racism; and just 14% feel that way about U.S. history. Parents can choose to provide their children with any book they believe is appropriate for them, said the Governors spokesperson Kollin Kropton. 48 opposites of viewpoint- words and phrases with opposite meaning. In Tennessee, these concerns collided in the case of Matthew Hawn. School later apologized to 5th U.S. Learn more. Now Tim Hardaway is out there saying Bol Bol is better than Wemby.BTW, I am being nice by saying it's "fake debate" show. Manipur horror: Old video of women paraded naked emerges, government Stanford law dean Jenny Martinez told students in an email reviewed by Reuters on Thursday that Tirien Steinbach is stepping down from her position as associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion to pursue another opportunity elsewhere after nearly two years in that role. Dec. 15, 2020. Washington, DC 20036, 130 West Second Street, Suite 410 Whenever I teach perspectives from African American people, I have to immediately compare and contrast it with a white narrative, said Hawn, a white self-described anti-racist teacher in a district where more than 94 percent of students are white. For any students who just want to know what it means to be gay and what it means to be trans, they can read this book for basic information that is scientifically accurate, Craig said. However, Hawns claim that there were no credible alternative perspectives is demonstrably false (see here, here or here for a few examples). They give brief insights into our people and places, our flora and fauna, and our past and present, from every corner of Colorado. Christine, a mother in Wisconsin who participated in the poll, is a member of that vocal minority. Contrary to Hawns claim, reported by Education Week, that the school district removed its contemporary issues class from the curriculum, we confirmed with Sullivan County officials that the course is still being taught. Bol Bol has better physical talent in the NBA than Victor Wembanyama @HardawaySr pic.twitter.com/BlilM9gDwJ. Enrollment in the 2014-15 school year was 1,200, [2] making it the fourth largest institution in the California Association of Independent Schools (CAIS). The Iowa City Community School District received two bomb threats after the same Twitter group highlighted that the district had the book in its junior high, too. Viewpoint discrimination is a concept in United States jurisprudence related to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. But because his question on a highly controversial topic is asked in a way that assumes the answer is already universally understood, it is the antithesis of both viewpoint diversity and critical thinking. Prior to his dismissal in July 2021, he had taught for 16 years in the Sullivan County school system, including courses on economics and world history. Craig said the high school students detailed that by middle school, some of their classmates had engaged in sexual activity and that sex was a common topic of discussion. Ganzy was also repeatedly subjected to racial slurs at school. By wide margins and regardless of their political affiliation parents express satisfaction with their children's schools and what is being taught in them. But under equal access laws, schools can't discriminate against a club based on its point of view. According to an . Social Media affects on Mental Health. Litigation around Satan Clubs arose in 2023 when a school board in Pennsylvania refused to allow a club to meet in an elementary school. The right solution, however, demands a willingness to apply the same approach to his progressive students and to a much wider range of issuesincluding many of those that touch identity, race and, yes, privilege. Last August, during a Viewpoint School student assembly around three months after George Floyd's in-custody death in Minneapolis, Greats played a YouTube video of then-14-year-old Royce Mann of. If a speech act is treated differently by a government entity based on the viewpoint it expresses, this is considered viewpoint discrimination. In fact, in 2022, almost half of parents, 47%, agree with the statement: "the pandemic has not disrupted my child's education." A widely circulated video showed Steinbach seemingly intervening on behalf of the protestors, saying the judge's presence was painful for some students. Karen Sloan reports on law firms, law schools, and the business of law. Some may be moved to act by their own intellectual curiosity, while others may be concerned about promoting democratic norms. For Craig, the two students on the committee played a crucial role in deciding the answer to the question. That's true in the NPR/Ipsos poll as well. Women and young girls are being trafficked and raped. "I question why Catholic Charities is being singled out when a number of other non-government organizations (NGOs) and city entities have received and are also receiving funding," said Flores, who added that Catholic Charities of the Rio Grande Valley was among several organizations in 2021 that qualified to receive reimbursement for expenses related to providing basic humanitarian care for people who had been approved by U.S. Customs and Border Patrol to enter the United States. (CNS/Bob Roller). DEI policies, while they may be well intended, in my opinion, sometimes can be incredibly mis-implemented We dont want to get it wrong in Douglas County, he said Tuesday. The undertone to Iowa Citys decision is that it will likely be moot in mere months. Viewpoint School is an independent school located in Calabasas, California. A teacher might reasonably wonder: Why should I bring up this controversial subject if it could cost me my job? In the recent dispute from Pennsylvania, the Satan Clubs organizers relied on Good News Club v. Milford Central School, a 2001 case from New York. That code states that, among other things, an educator shall[n]ot unreasonably deny the student access to varying points of view. While one could reasonably debate whether such a code is a good or a bad legislative step, it does appear, based on the available evidence, that Hawns classroom behavior was inconsistent with the spirit in which it was written. Slavery Reparation in California. Discussing Opposing Views in the Classroom - Gale Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the worlds largest multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day. Brownsville | Truck Simulator Wiki | Fandom Florida school system has closed investigation into teacher who - CNN Gift Article. Jim Ondelacy is a Native American and a Democrat living in North Richland Hills, Texas, outside Fort Worth. 1 overall NBA draft pick Victor Wembanyama, the former NBA star turned analyst said. Addressing it requires a willingness to think broadly and a commitment to teaching in a manner that prioritizes the presentation of a variety of viewpoints on equal moral ground. Frustrated, the 14-year-old reported the racism he was experiencing to district officials in an email but no one contacted him. On the other hand, the fact that it wasnt implemented was one reason some voters rejected a critical school tax measure on the ballot in 2022. 2.1 Defining Controversies in Science: No Mere Disagreement. Editors note: A slightly different version of this article was first published by the American Enterprise Institute. Viewpoint Diversity in the Classroom Benefits Everyone But as a recent case in Tennessee shows, both the left and right need to work harder to promote a diversity of ideas in schools Ilana Redstone January 12, 2022 Consider more than one argument. In its requests, filed on Sept. 1, 2021, CatholicVote sought all communications between U.S. Customs and Border Patrol and Bishop Daniel Flores of Brownsville, Texas, as well as the Diocese of Brownsville, Catholic Charities of the Rio Grande Valley, the Humanitarian Respite Center in McAllen, Texas, and Pimentel. In fact, in our poll, about a third of parents say they "don't know" how their child's school addresses sexuality, gender identity, racism or patriotism. Are they paying for transportation, flights, buses, or other services with government money? The named groups include Catholics for Choice, which supports abortion rights, and Faith in Action. Tirien Steinbach was criticized for defending protestors who disrupted comments of federal judge, School later apologized to 5th U.S. A story that became a flashpoint in national conversations around the effects of CRT bans is reaching its denouement: This past week, a hearing officer appointed to adjudicate the case ruled that the Sullivan County, Tennessee, school board was justified in firing high school teacher Matthew Hawn earlier this year. And that's the problem.. An equity policy was adopted by the school board in March 2021 after years of discussion and input from a number of groups. Image Credit: Hill Street Studios, Copyright 2023 Mercatus Center at George Mason University, An Old Recipe for a More Balanced Discourse, Walmart Didnt Kill the Small Town, It Is the Small Town, Crossing the Rubicon on the Politicization of Education, The Conservative Resurgence Across the Atlantic. Circuit Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan. The event was interrupted by students who said Duncan has taken positions that threatened the rights of LGBTQ people, immigrants, Black voters, women and others. NBA analyst slammed for controversial Bol Bol, Victor Wembanyama take But also if youre in the closet and you dont know how this works and you dont want to ask your parents because you dont know how they feel, youre not going to have that resource.. However, the trial and conviction of Derek Chauvin later that same spring brought him new challenges. Consider our age guideline How do I start the application process? To be sure, Coatess argument warrants serious consideration, and it reflects a position held by a substantial portion of voters on the left. His 2019 book, How the Other Half Learns, based on a year of observations at New York Citys Success Academy. Social Inequality Fact. "They understand what's happening with Black Lives Matter but they don't really understand where it came from and how it started," he says. High agreed supervision is not a bad idea but added that having it openly available in a library can be valuable for some teenagers. For me, it was a good resource to be able to understand what being queer really was and say I understand this, this is me but I was also really nervous, said High. In an increasingly intellectually diverse world, though, children are bound to encounter ideas with which they disagree and I would argue each encounter can sharpen their critical thinking. A review of Iowa Citys sex education curriculum from a letter sent to parents shows it does include discussions of dating and relationships, including online dating apps. 3:21-cv-01429-SB) after first attempting to reach a pre-litigation settlement through its conciliation process. This Book is Gay and Iowas looming school library book ban, Police are investigating a Cedar County fatal crash, Nonprofits star-studded celebrity softball game coming to Cedar Rapids Saturday, Dubuque opening public cooling centers to combat extreme temperatures, Univ. If it makes you uncomfortable, thats your decision, you dont have to have your kids read that book if you dont want to, said High. The policy, swept up in a national furor over misinformation about critical race theory, was a key reason the new board majority was elected in 2021. (Instrumental diversity is described as strength in collaboration among individuals possessing different skills, specialties, plans and techniques to pursue common, agreed upon goals.) Personality and learning approach diversity had been considered. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. Also on Feb. 4, CatholicVote filed a second lawsuit, against the U.S. Department of Justice seeking communications between the department's Office of the Solicitor General and a host of Catholic bishops, individuals and organizations. She described it like a textbook, comparing it to the content already taught in sex ed in middle school. This Comment will evaluate viewpoint-based restrictions on school-sponsored speech in the context of recent interpretations of the Hazelwood standard. "I really hope the district can get behind a way of implementing this," she says. When the government engages in content discrimination, it is restricting speech on a given subject matter. "It's . She also doesn't approve of her son, who is in high school, being asked what pronouns he prefers to use. 2023 Colorado Public Radio. Board member Kaylee Winegar said when she assumed office, she wanted to repeal and replace the policy, feeling that it did more harm than good. This year's responses showed positive trends as the nation continues to recover from the worst of the pandemic. When the mother of a Black ninth grader at a private school in Charlotte, N.C., learned last month that his English class was going to be studying August Wilson 's "Fences . Finally, the act forbids people who are not affiliated with the school, such as local residents or parents, from directing, conducting, controlling or regularly attending club activities. That prompted the Iowa City School District to initiate its review process, a rarely used procedure that all Iowa school districts have in some form to respond to complaints about classroom or library material. "I respect the confidence they give me and I use it responsibly to care for the families with basic necessities like water, food and a place to rest their heads. All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. We deliver world-ready graduates who are ready to excel, lead, thrive, and serve. Banned: Books on race and sexuality are disappearing from Texas schools in record numbers. *Controversial or those with opposing views are marked with a (C). They are leaving dire circumstances back in their home countries, risking everything to come here with the hope that they can find a safe place to raise their families," said Pimentel, who added that her agency's mission is to offer a humanitarian response aimed at restoring human dignity. The First Amendment was designed for this very purpose., Copyright 20102023, The Conversation Media Group Ltd. A Christian activist group demonstrates outside the Satanic Temples SatanCon, a convention held in Boston, on April 28, 2023. But not all hot-button topics in education are about what goes on in class. Viewpoint and CampusPoint Sued by EEOC for Disability Discrimination Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. Hawn used critical thinking to show his conservative students that the Tennessee income tax is a complex policy with both upsides and downsides. Much of the book addresses basic questions of sexual and gender identity: defining gender and sexuality, explaining the biology and history of both, discussing how to handle hatred, and coming out to parents. Proposed legislation threatens viewpoint diversity in - Brookings A. Good teachers are difficult to come by. In doing that I was attempting to have my students explore the subject of race in America and to think independently by asking them to examine privilege from two perspectives. As the start of the school year rapidly approaches, controversy cant be far behind. Texas A&M president retires after fallout over journalist as professor Browse an unrivalled portfolio of real-time and historical market data and insights from worldwide sources and experts. Ralph Wilson, a researcher who studies how partisan donors back the culture war, says these groups imply that they represent a silent majority of conservative-leaning parents. But as a recent case in Tennessee shows, both the left and right need to work harder to promote a diversity of ideas in schools. Judicial Watch, a conservative activist group that often files information requests targeting liberal politicians, joined CatholicVote in its new federal lawsuit, which they filed Feb. 4 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Stanford Law assistant dean embroiled in judge's free-speech It was designed to fix inequitable practices in the district, ensure all student groups are represented in the curriculum, and that the district has a diverse teacher workforce. Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionals, Law firm Clifford Chance posts increased revenue, stalled profits, Shearman real estate finance partner is latest exit as merger looms, Corporate attorneys dont want to pay law firms for ChatGPT whenthey could use it themselves, How litigation funding drives progress in the ESG agenda, US sues Texas over floating border barriers, China to step up policy adjustments amid tortuous recovery, Mexico urges US court to revive $10 billion lawsuit against gun makers, White House says Biden will veto Republican-backed bills over spending cuts. The action on the equity policy came hours after a rally against racism outside district headquarters and a board discussion about statistics showing large gaps between different racial and ethnic groups in dropout rates, bullying, and discipline rates.