The Doctor awakens in the museum of an alien culture seven hundred years in the future, where Voyager is thought to have been a Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan "Somewhere, halfway across the galaxy, I hope, Captain Janeway is spinning in her grave." 4x23. Two million Kyrians slaughtered within days. Of course, there is a price to pay. Further into the future, a group of Kyrians and Vaskans stand around a viewscreen, watching these events unfold. WebStar Trek: Voyager (TV Series) Living Witness (1998) Parents Guide Add to guide . How can kaiju exist in nature and not significantly alter civilization? From Blink of an Eye to Living Witness to Counterpoint, Voyager managed to build classic Star Trek morality plays around intense sci-fi elements. This simulation and this museum are a testament to that struggle. Garrett Wang as Harry Kim, operations officer. Holocaust Museum was a model of sorts for the Kyrian museum. Menu. The Doctor comes to grips with the new time he's in, looking at the artifacts around him. Webbrianjohnson-20043 9 October 2018 It's 700 years in the future of the typical voyager timeline and an alien culture voyager interacted with on their journey home still blames WebStar Trek: Voyager (TV Series) Living Witness (1998) Mary Anne McGarry: Tabris. Movies. Star Trek: Voyager" Living Witness (TV Episode WebLiving Witness (1998) 91 of 102 Robert Picardo, Marie Chambers, and Henry Woronicz in Star Trek: Voyager (1995). I didn't ever see them as the way this episode portrays them. The Doctor awakens in the museum of an alien culture seven hundred years in the future, where Voyager is thought to have been a passing warship full of cold-blooded killers. are so freaking stupid QUARREN: We reconstructed it from a partial schematic found in the Cyrik ocean, which was badly damaged by corrosion. They managed to find ways to solve issues & make their way home together in the end. WebLiving Witness (1998) 93 of 102 Robert Beltran and Robert Picardo in Star Trek: Voyager (1995). What happened to the doctor backup? The Trek Nation - Living Witness - TrekToday WebRobert Picardo in Star Trek: Voyager (1995) Home. Living Witness Janeway then meets the captive Tedran and an associate in a room on the ship and ends up executing both personally when they won't surrender. Living Witness (episode) | Memory Alpha | Fandom Sign in to rate and Watchlist for personalized recommendations. Who counts as pupils or as a student in Germany? Quarren refutes his argument, as The Doctor was there at the events and no one should deny what he saw. Granted, this looks like the briefing room, but these aren't the people I knew! An aspect that needed to be addressed, however, was the museum's location. ", "From my perspective, I saw them all only a few days ago. Does this mean that they are wrong? Stay tuned to StarTrek.com for more Anthony De Longis as Jal Culluh, First Maje of the Kazon -Nistrim. People Kate Mulgrew. List of Star Trek: Voyager cast members - Wikipedia The Doctor initially refuses to remain, telling him that for hundreds of years Tedran was a martyr to his people and he doesn't have the right to take that away. 20 Phase Cannons? WebStar Trek: Voyager's regular cast extremely enjoyed playing the collection of malevolent roles that differed from the characters the performers were used to portraying. Star Trek I don't think this question is a duplication of this post, because this one is about the whole episode, as well as what really happened to the crew. Recurring cast Simon Billig as Hogan, engineering officer and former member of the Maquis until his death in 2373. Why does ksh93 not support %T format specifier of its built-in printf in AIX? Chakotay and Kim interrogate a Kyrian prisoner, who starts talking when the Doctor (here an android with eyes like Data's) injects the Kyrian with a substance to dissolve his neural tissue. It took centuries for us to undo the damage that Captain Janeway had done, and the Kyrian struggle for equality is far from over. It turns out, however, that what she must do is aid this guy in his attack on an adversarial planet. Constructing the past on Star Trek: Voyager. Most especially the leading performances by Henry Woronicz (quarren) and Robert Picardo are stunning and flawless. There are still warlike factions on the planet and the power people don't want to give up their stranglehold. Cast. as Captain Kathryn Janeway Robert Beltran. Was the release of "Barbie" intentionally coordinated to be on the same day as "Oppenheimer"? Later that night, Quarren begins a dictation describing how he's had trouble accessing the data on the storage device and is going to try to use tools from the simulation on the device because they might be more compatible. Shortly after the making of the episode, he said, ". The Best of Star Trek: Voyager: Living Witness - YouTube This is a compelling episode of Voyager--one that should cause people to not blindly accept those "facts" put into history books, but to keep an open mind about what really happened, as well as to always look at all sides of events. They only had partial information, a partial plan of Voyager and constructed a narrative that fit with their world view. WebPosted by mirage2101. In the Voyager episode Living Witness a backup copy of the Doctor sets off to follow Voyager's path, to see if they ever made it home. Quarren informs him that the evidence has been examined carefully, and, furthermore, a data storage device, buried nine meters beneath the ruins of Kesef and that came from Voyager, has been recently uncovered. It was wonderful--with deliciously evil performances by the cast. The Vaskan leader says it vindicates his ancestors' belief that they didn't start the war, but a furious Kyrian says the Vaskans will use this as one more excuse to oppress and vilify her people, which proves that it's just one more Vaskan lie. People Robert Beltran, Robert Picardo Janeway demands complete surrender from Tedrin, who tells Daleth that they could have settled their differences peacefully, without involving an alien warship. The Kyrians had believed a lie and the Doctor's witness made them question their beliefs. 4:19m Star Trek: Voyager. Bryan Fuller remembered, ", Joe Menosky enjoyed taking part in writing the characters differently from how they usually were, in scenes such as the one in which conflict breaks out in the warship, The episode's final draft script was submitted on, The shooting script of this episode referred to the Kyrian-envisioned members of, During the making of the episode, actor/director, Robert Picardo's performance here was a highlight of the episode for both Tim Russ and visual effects supervisor, Robert Picardo himself was impressed by Janeway actress, Tim Russ not only directed this episode but also appeared as his usual character of Tuvok. Garrett Wang and the Diversity of Star Trek: Voyager. While the Vaskans are keen to hear his side, the Kyrians are very angry over The Doctor's version of events which paint them in a more negative light. Full Cast and Crew | Official Sites | Company Credits | Filming & Production | Technical Specs. Star Trek The Doctor states that he should be shut down, because as an EMH he is obliged to help people, and his continued presence is causing riots and intense anger among both races and points out that what really happened is open to interpretation. A docent explains that it is 700 years since Voyager passed through the system, but the effects of the warship's brutality are still being felt. Later, we see the Doctors account how Voyager was boarded with those attack parties. STAR TREK VOYAGER Metacritic Reviews. Quarren says they drew reasonable conclusions based on the evidence, but The Doctor points out that the fact they believed Voyager was trying to get home to Mars rather than Earth only highlights the problem. Movies. This episode reminds me of the famous Indian parable about the blind men and the elephant. Robert Picardo (who commented that the evil versions of the characters were "like Hitler and the S.S. ") noted, " It was fun for the actors to do. @Foxy : "Heavily armed" armed is context (and adversary) dependent. Janeway being portrayed as a female version of Adolf Hitler, the beatings, the killings of k.yrians, a star wars version of star trek with the wipe out of a planet, & ongoing violence. It only takes a minute to sign up. Cast (in credits order) complete, awaiting verification. Voyager Status: Released. Security responds in engineering, but the Kyrians have already killed three engineering crewmen and take Seven of Nine and another crewman hostage. TV Shows. WebStar Trek: Voyager (TV Series) Living Witness (1998) Release Info. That being said, watching the Doctor defend them against the falsified "history" being presented was superb. Living Witness Premiered at: 1998-04-29. With us again this week is our favorite cheesemonger, Nicola. The last minute is what Star Trek is all about, Star Trek: Voyager Season 4 (1997-98) (Average: 8.12). WebThis episode we cover "Living Witness", Season 4 Episode 23 of Star Trek: Voyager. It's thoroughly unrealistic, and doesn't address the troubling questions raised, like: if Janeway wasn't really a Hitler, does that mean that it's fine to believe Hitler wasn't really a Hitler, or was only "a Hitler" from the point of view of the winnners since he would have justified his actions had he successfully conquered the world, wiping away anyone who spoke against him? Movies. Paris. He tries to warn the rest of the ship. Janeway then focuses on locating the Kyrian leader, Tedran. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. We never learned anything about either the Vaskans or Kyrians beyond their hatreds: I still have no idea what the war was over in the first place. Star Trek: Voyager's regular cast extremely enjoyed playing the collection of malevolent roles that differed from the characters the performers were used to portraying. Janeway agrees and then the ship shakes. Star Trek Kate Mulgrew. Living witness STAR TREK VOYAGER Executive producer Rick Berman was involved in settling this issue. The actor/director declared of his role, "[, Tim Russ was surprised that this episode involved the use of as many as three stages. What about this episode that seems to be out of the scope of the story? One of Joshos favourite episodes of the science-fiction television series Star Trek: Voyager (1995-2001) deals with the problems inherent in reconstructing the past, how the past influences the present, and how it paves the way to the future.